Hit on the Head: Three Questions That Matter in Traumatic Brain Injury

A practical approach to head trauma in dogs and cats

Head trauma can be an intimidating presentation. A dog arrives after a road traffic accident. A cat has fallen from a height. There is blood around the face, abnormal pupils, an animal that cannot stand and understandably distressed owners wanting to know whether their pet will survive.

Our instinct as vets is often to go straight to the nervous system, but the first rule of head trauma is surprisingly simple:

Don’t start with the brain.

The neurological examination matters, but it comes after the things that can kill the patient more quickly. And once we do reach the neurological examination, it doesn’t necessarily need to be complicated either.

The Modified Glasgow Coma Scale (MGCS) provides a structured method of assessing traumatic brain injury. It is useful, validated and gives us valuable prognostic information. But in general practice, particularly in the first few minutes of an emergency, there is an even simpler way of thinking about it.

It comes down to three questions:

Is the mentation normal?
Can the patient walk?
What are the pupils doing?

Those three observations can tell us an enormous amount.

 

First things first: forget the neurology

Not literally, of course.

But when an animal arrives following significant head trauma, neurological assessment should initially be towards the bottom of the priority list.

The starting point is exactly the same as for any other major trauma patient:

Airway. Breathing. Circulation.

Is the airway patent? Is there blood, fluid or trauma compromising it?

Is the patient ventilating adequately? Is there concurrent thoracic trauma, pulmonary injury or pneumothorax?

And is the circulation adequate? Assess pulse quality, heart rate and rhythm, mucous membranes and blood pressure.

This distinction matters because hypovolaemic shock can itself profoundly alter mentation. A shocked, poorly perfused animal may appear neurologically much worse than it really is. Trying to prognosticate from the neurological examination before restoring adequate perfusion can therefore be seriously misleading.

Treat the shock first. Then assess the brain.

 

The brain injury we can actually influence

It is useful to divide traumatic brain injury (TBI) into two components:

Primary brain injury happens at the moment of impact. It includes the direct mechanical effects of trauma such as contusion, haemorrhage and axonal injury. By the time the patient reaches us, this has already happened.

We cannot undo it.

Secondary brain injury develops subsequently. Cerebral oedema, ischaemia and alterations in cerebral blood flow can worsen the initial injury over the following hours.

And this is the important bit:

Secondary brain injury is potentially modifiable.

Much of our management is therefore not about somehow “treating the concussion”. It is about preventing an injured brain from becoming more injured.

Three things are particularly important:

  • blood pressure
  • oxygen
  • carbon dioxide

The reason becomes clearer if we think about cerebral perfusion pressure:

CPP = mean arterial blood pressure − intracranial pressure

As intracranial pressure (ICP) rises, cerebral perfusion pressure falls. Equally, if systemic blood pressure falls, cerebral perfusion pressure falls. Either route can ultimately reduce blood flow to an already compromised brain.

 

Blood pressure matters more than you might think

The normal brain has an impressive ability to maintain relatively constant cerebral blood flow despite changes in systemic blood pressure – cerebral autoregulation.

Following traumatic brain injury, however, the blood-brain barrier and these autoregulatory mechanisms may be disrupted. Cerebral blood flow can then become much more dependent upon systemic blood pressure.

This is why hypotension is such bad news in a head-trauma patient.

There can sometimes be a reluctance to administer intravenous fluids to an animal with suspected cerebral oedema because of a fear of “making the brain swelling worse”, but leaving a shocked head-trauma patient hypotensive is potentially far more damaging.

If the patient is hypovolaemic, restore the circulating volume.

Fluid therapy should be titrated against the patient’s perfusion parameters and blood pressure rather than withheld simply because a brain injury is suspected.

 

Oxygen and carbon dioxide: don’t forget the basics

Hypoxaemia also has consequences for the injured brain.

As arterial oxygen falls, cerebral vessels dilate in an attempt to increase cerebral blood flow. That increases cerebral blood volume and can contribute to increasing ICP.

Supplemental oxygen is therefore a very simple and potentially important intervention following significant head trauma.

Carbon dioxide is perhaps even more interesting because it is a potent regulator of cerebral blood flow – hypercapnia causes cerebral vasodilation. Cerebral blood volume increases and ICP can increase with it.

Hypocapnia does the opposite – but that doesn’t mean we should routinely hyperventilate head-trauma patients. Excessive hypocapnia causes cerebral vasoconstriction and can reduce cerebral blood flow sufficiently to cause ischaemia.

For most patients the aim is therefore adequate ventilation and normocapnia, rather than aggressive hyperventilation. Ventilatory intervention becomes particularly relevant in severely obtunded, stuporous or comatose patients that are failing to ventilate adequately.

 

Now we can look at the brain

Once the patient has been stabilised, we can ask what the neurological examination tells us.

The formal Modified Glasgow Coma Scale was adapted from the Glasgow Coma Scale used in human medicine.

It evaluates three broad areas:

  • level of consciousness
  • motor activity
  • brainstem reflexes.

Each is scored from 1–6, producing a total score between 3 and 18.

The lower the score, the more severe the neurological dysfunction. In the scheme used here, scores of 15–18 are associated with a good prognosis, 9–14 with a guarded prognosis and 3–8 with a grave prognosis. Importantly, the score is not simply useful at presentation. Repeating it gives us an objective way of determining whether a patient is improving or deteriorating.

The problem?

In an emergency, nobody really wants another complicated scoring system to remember.

So, I use what I rather unimaginatively call the:

Modified Modified Glasgow Coma Scale

It isn’t intended to replace the formal MGCS. It is a way of extracting its most clinically useful principles and turning them into three questions that can be answered in seconds.

 

Question 1: Is the mentation normal?

This is probably the most useful initial neurological observation.

Think of mentation as a spectrum:

Normal → obtunded → stuporous → comatose

An obtunded patient is sleepy or less responsive but remains aware of its environment.

A stuporous patient requires strong stimulation to generate a response.

A comatose patient cannot be roused.

The further we move along that spectrum, the greater our concern about significant brain dysfunction.

This also gives us something wonderfully simple to monitor.

A patient that progresses from stuporous to obtunded over several hours is moving in the right direction.

One progressing from obtunded to stuporous is not.

Trend is often more valuable than a single examination.

 

Question 2: Can the patient walk?

Again, keep it simple.

If the patient can walk, even if ataxic, this is very different from a recumbent patient with little purposeful motor activity.

In non-ambulatory patients, posture can provide additional information.

Decerebrate rigidity is particularly concerning. These patients demonstrate rigid extension of all four limbs, often with extension of the head and neck, and have severely altered mentation. This indicates severe brainstem dysfunction and carries a guarded-to-poor prognosis.

Don’t confuse this with decerebellate posture. Cerebellar disease can also cause dramatic extensor rigidity, but consciousness should remain intact. That difference in mentation is crucial.

 

Question 3: What are the pupils doing?

This is where head trauma can become unnecessarily confusing.

Pupils are useful, but they need context.

Pupil size is controlled by competing parasympathetic and sympathetic influences. Light stimulates parasympathetic pupillary constriction; fear, pain and excitement increase sympathetic tone and cause dilation.

Anyone who has examined a frightened cat knows how dramatic that sympathetic mydriasis can be.

Primary ocular trauma can also alter pupil size.

So, an abnormal pupil in a bright, responsive animal does not automatically mean catastrophic intracranial disease.

Pupil size becomes particularly useful when it accompanies a severe change in mentation.

In a severely mentally depressed head-trauma patient, marked miosis can accompany significant intracranial disease and brain swelling.

Progression towards fixed mydriasis – sometimes initially asymmetric, or even seen as the pupil dilating towards normal – is much more worrying. With increasing ICP, transtentorial herniation can compress the midbrain and parasympathetic component of cranial nerve III, producing dilated poorly responsive pupils.
In that clinical context, mydriasis can be an ominous sign.

So rather than looking at the pupils in isolation, remember:

Mentation first. Pupils second.

 

Put it together: three questions

For the patient in front of you following head trauma:

Is the mentation normal?
If not, how abnormal is it?

Can the patient walk?
If not, what purposeful movement and posture are present?

What are the pupils doing?
Particularly if mentation is severely abnormal.

That is the modified modified Glasgow Coma Scale.

It won’t give you a numerical MGCS score, and it shouldn’t be presented as a validated replacement for one. What it does give you is a rapid mental framework for recognising the patient who needs more aggressive management.

And then you can perform and record the formal MGCS when circumstances allow.

Treat the patient in tiers

The same philosophy can make treatment much less intimidating.

Rather than throwing every possible therapy at every head-trauma patient, treatment can be escalated according to severity and – importantly – response to treatment.

Tier 1: extracranial stabilisation

This applies to every significant head-trauma patient.

Correct shock. Maintain blood pressure. Provide oxygen. Ensure adequate ventilation. Provide appropriate analgesia. Monitor the patient carefully.

Then reassess the neurological status.

A patient that becomes brighter after restoration of its circulating volume has already told you something extremely useful.

Tier 2: intracranial stabilisation

This is for the more severely affected patient, particularly one with a MGCS below 8 or a deteriorating neurological examination despite initial stabilisation.

Now our attention turns towards suspected raised ICP.

Hyperosmolar therapy can be considered. Options include mannitol at 0.25–1 g/kg IV over 10–20 minutes or 7.5% hypertonic saline at 2–4 ml/kg in cats and 4–6 ml/kg in dogs.

There is an important caveat:

Do not reach for hyperosmolar therapy before correcting hypovolaemia.

Mannitol in particular can cause diuresis and worsen intravascular volume depletion.

Reducing ICP is of little benefit if we simultaneously destroy cerebral perfusion by allowing systemic blood pressure to fall.

Ventilatory support may also be required in severely affected patients with inadequate ventilation and hypercapnia.

Tier 3: imaging and, occasionally, surgery

This is perhaps one of the most useful messages for general practice:

Not every animal with head trauma needs a brain scan.

Imaging does not stabilise the patient.

And CT or MRI generally requires sedation or anaesthesia – precisely the thing we may wish to avoid in an unstable patient.

So, ask a simple question before imaging:

What am I going to do differently with the result?

If a patient is neurologically improving with supportive management, finding a skull fracture or cerebral contusion may not alter treatment.

Advanced imaging becomes much more important when the patient is failing to improve or deteriorating despite appropriate medical management, or when there are specific concerns such as an open or severely depressed skull fracture.

CT is particularly useful for evaluating the skull and can identify acute intracranial haemorrhage. MRI provides superior evaluation of the brain parenchyma, haemorrhage and contusion.

But importantly, traumatic brain injury does not require an abnormal scan. Concussion and diffuse axonal injury may produce profound clinical signs without an obvious structural abnormality on imaging.

The most useful diagnostic test may be time

One of the great advantages of the MGCS is that it turns a subjective neurological examination into something we can follow.

But even without calculating the complete score every time, repeat the same three questions:

Is the mentation better?
Can the patient walk?
What are the pupils doing?

A patient that is becoming brighter, developing more purposeful movement and maintaining appropriate pupils is giving us very different information from one becoming progressively less responsive.

The neurological examination is therefore not simply something we perform at admission.

It is a monitoring tool.

And in many head-trauma patients, the direction of travel tells us more than the first examination ever could.

The Movement take-home

Head trauma can look complicated, but the initial approach doesn’t need to be.

Start outside the skull before worrying about what is happening inside it.

Treat airway, breathing and circulation. Correct shock. Maintain oxygenation and ventilation. Then assess the nervous system.

And when faced with the neurological examination, start with three questions:

Is the mentation normal?
Can the patient walk?
What are the pupils doing?

Use the formal MGCS when you can, but perhaps keep this modified modified Glasgow Coma Scale in the back of your mind when a head-trauma patient comes through the door.

Because sometimes good neurology isn’t about doing a longer neurological examination.

It’s about knowing which three things matter most.